When Chrisley Knows Best first graced television screens, viewers fell in love with the tight-knit, charming, and often hilarious Chrisley family. But behind the laughter, glitz, and southern flair,

reality struck hard when family patriarch Todd Chrisley and his wife Julie Chrisley were sentenced to lengthy prison terms — 12 and 7 years respectively — for financial crimes.

What followed wasn’t just a media spectacle; it was a heartbreaking question of guardianship, legacy, and what it truly means to hold a family together when everything falls apart.

At the heart of this emotional storm is Chloe Chrisley, the couple’s beloved granddaughter, and Grayson Chrisley, their teenage son. When the verdict came down, fans immediately wondered: Who will care for Chloe and Grayson now?

In a heartfelt moment on her podcast, Savannah Chrisley revealed that the decision had already been made. If her parents went to jail, she would become the legal guardian for both Chloe and Grayson. Her announcement was filled with strength and conviction — but as the months have gone by, fans across social media have started to question: Was Savannah really the best choice?

A Family Divided by Choice

On platforms like Reddit and Facebook, discussions exploded. Many viewers voiced unwavering support for Savannah, admiring her devotion and maturity in stepping up during crisis. But others weren’t so sure.

One fan admitted it might be an unpopular opinion but confessed they believed Todd and Julie might have overlooked an obvious choice — someone else within the family who could have been better suited to guide Chloe and Grayson through their emotional and developmental years.

That name? Lindsie Chrisley.

“She’s already a mom,” one commenter wrote. “She understands routines, discipline, and emotional balance. She could have been a stable mother figure for Chloe.”

The argument seemed reasonable — but not everyone agreed.

Mixed Feelings About Lindsie

The reactions were swift and passionate. Some fans supported the idea, recognizing Lindsie’s parenting experience as a valuable asset. “Lindsie has already walked the walk,” one user wrote. “She knows what raising a child actually means.”

But others were quick to remind the internet that Lindsie’s relationship with her father and siblings has been strained for years. The Chrisley family’s estrangement from her was well-documented, and many fans pointed out that Chloe and Grayson barely know her personally.

Moreover, Lindsie’s own life situation presented complications. She doesn’t live in Nashville, and her co-parenting agreement with her ex-husband might make relocating — or taking in two more children — legally and logistically impossible. “You can’t just uproot your own child’s life to raise someone else’s,” another fan noted.

Still, the question lingered: Was Savannah chosen out of love and trust — or out of convenience?

Could Nanny Faye Have Been the Heart They Needed?

Then, fans began turning their attention toward another beloved figure — Nanny Faye, the family matriarch and Todd’s mother. For years, she has been the comedic anchor of Chrisley Knows Best, her quick wit and wisdom making her a fan favorite.

While some might dismiss the idea of an elderly woman taking on two young dependents, others saw deeper potential. Nanny Faye embodies something rare — a stability rooted in warmth and humor.

“Sometimes, what a child needs isn’t structure or strategy,” a fan commented. “It’s laughter. It’s storytelling. It’s a sense that life can still be joyful even when it’s hard.”

In a house filled with uncertainty, Nanny Faye could bring the kind of emotional security that no amount of legal guardianship papers can provide. Her home would smell like biscuits and memories. Every photo on her wall would tell a story. And for children like Chloe and Grayson, who’ve already lost so much, that could be priceless.

Of course, the practical side remains an obstacle. Nanny Faye may not have the stamina or resources to handle the daily logistics alone — school meetings, sports practices, and emotional growing pains. But as part of a support system, she could have been the emotional cornerstone, the “heart quarterback” guiding everyone else.

The Case for Chase and Lindsay

Chase Chrisley, Savannah’s brother, also entered fan discussions. While he’s often portrayed as the carefree sibling, some viewers see his authenticity as a strength. “Kids don’t need perfect guardians,” one commenter argued. “They need honest ones.”

Chase has made mistakes — but he’s also shown growth, humility, and the ability to learn from them. For Chloe and Grayson, having a role model who’s transparent about his flaws might actually be more valuable than one who strives for perfection.

As for Lindsie, despite her distance from the family, some fans still hold out hope that reconciliation could open new doors. Lindsie’s life experience outside the “Chrisley bubble” gives her a unique perspective. She understands boundaries, conflict, and healing — lessons that could teach Chloe about strength and self-worth in a world that won’t always be kind.

What About Kyle?

It’s impossible to talk about Chloe without mentioning her father, Kyle Chrisley. His relationship with both his parents and daughter has been complicated by past struggles with addiction and mental health.

But redemption stories are not foreign to this family. Some fans have wondered if, with support, Kyle could take a more active role — not necessarily as full guardian, but as a co-parenting presence.

“Imagine how healing it would be,” one viewer wrote, “for Chloe to see her dad fighting for his place in her life — and succeeding.”

Such a move would not only mend personal wounds but could also rewrite the Chrisley family narrative from one of loss to one of generational healing.

Savannah’s Role: A Heavy Burden Worn Gracefully

In fairness, Savannah has carried this role with remarkable grace. She’s young, ambitious, and fiercely protective of her siblings. She manages schedules, attends meetings, and offers emotional stability despite her own pain.

Her devotion is undeniable. But fans worry about burnout — the weight of responsibility placed on a woman still navigating her own adulthood. As one commenter said, “Savannah’s doing amazing, but she’s been forced to grow up overnight.”

The question, then, isn’t whether Savannah is capable. It’s whether she should have to do it alone.

The Bigger Picture: Family as the True Guardian

In the end, maybe the debate isn’t about one “right” person. Perhaps the best guardian for Chloe isn’t a single figure — but a family constellation.

Imagine a shared guardianship of sorts:

• Savannah as the primary caretaker and decision-maker.
• Nanny Faye as the emotional compass and comforter.
• Chase as the big brother who brings laughter and perspective.
• Lindsie as a bridge to healing old wounds.
• Kyle as a father reclaiming his role with pride and purpose.

Together, they could provide Chloe with something richer than any legal arrangement — a community of love, growth, and accountability.

Final Thoughts

Did Todd and Julie Chrisley choose the wrong guardian for Chloe? Maybe not. But they might have chosen too narrowly.

In a family this complex, this vibrant, and this deeply intertwined with both pain and love, the best guardian isn’t a person — it’s a village.

If that village can work together, Chloe’s future might not just be secure; it could be extraordinary.

Because in the end, guardianship isn’t about who fills out the paperwork — it’s about who shows up, day after day, with open arms, a steady heart, and a willingness to grow alongside the child they love.

And that, perhaps, is the true legacy the Chrisleys can still build.