Salem is about to be set ablaze with one of the most electrifying rumors of the year: could Marcy Miller be returning to Days of Our Lives as the authentic Abigail Deveraux this December?

Soap opera fans everywhere are buzzing, speculation running wild as whispers of Abigail’s dramatic resurgence circulate across social media, forums, and fan communities.

With Salem’s history of shocking resurrections, hidden secrets, and jaw-dropping twists, the prospect of Miller’s return promises to reshape the landscape of the Dera and Horton families,

sending shockwaves through the hearts and minds of viewers.

Abigail’s Tumultuous Journey

To appreciate the seismic potential of Miller’s rumored return, it’s essential to trace the journey of Abigail Deveraux, a character whose storylines have consistently left fans both thrilled and heartbroken. Born in 1992 to Jack Deveraux and Jennifer Horton, Abigail evolved from a wide-eyed innocent into a woman of intense emotional depth, navigating mental health struggles, forbidden romances, and family legacies that could crush lesser souls.

Abigail’s character has been portrayed by multiple actresses over the years, each adding layers to her multifaceted personality—from Megan and Michael Nelson in her childhood to Ashley Benson during her teen years, and later, adult portrayals by Kate Mansi and, crucially, Marcy Miller. Miller first assumed the role in 2016, immediately imbuing Abigail with a blend of vulnerability, fierce determination, and a complexity that resonated with fans worldwide. Her portrayal earned multiple Daytime Emmy nominations, a testament to her mastery of the character’s intricate emotional landscape.

Miller’s Impact on Salem

Miller’s tenure from 2016 to 2018 included some of the most memorable arcs in recent Days of Our Lives history. Storylines such as the infamous “Abby in the Attic” explored Abigail’s struggles with dissociative identity disorder, interweaving psychological thriller elements with classic soap melodrama. Her entanglements with Chad Deveraux (Billy Flynn) and Stefan DiMera (Tyler Christopher) electrified audiences, and the super couple chemistry between Abigail and Chad—affectionately dubbed “Chabby”—cemented their place in daytime television lore.

The poignancy of Abigail’s character was amplified by Miller’s departure in 2018 to focus on personal life events, leaving fans yearning for her return. Miller reprised the role in 2020, delving into darker territory, including investigative journalism pursuits and confrontations with villains such as Gwen Rizcik and Clyde Weston. The storyline culminated in Abigail’s shocking death in 2022—a moment that left Salem in mourning and viewers questioning the permanence of death in their beloved soap.

The Mystery of the Empty Coffin

Abigail’s apparent demise didn’t quell curiosity for long. Hints and whispers emerged, suggesting that the character might not be gone for good. From clandestine messages to DNA tests and the emergence of a fake Abigail played by Annalyn McCord, the groundwork for a dramatic return was laid. Chad’s desperate embrace of the imposter revealed the emotional complexity of the story while teasing the possibility that the real Abigail was still out there, her fate shrouded in mystery.

The revelation of the impostor plot, orchestrated by Clyde Weston and others, concluded with the shocking discovery that Abigail’s coffin was empty—no body, no closure, only the tantalizing suggestion that Miller’s Abigail could still be alive, waiting for her moment to return. This cliffhanger has fueled intense fan speculation, with viewers imagining everything from Abigail in captivity to her suffering from amnesia or even brainwashing, her memories fragmented, and her return set to disrupt Salem in unimaginable ways.

December’s Storm: A Vivid Scenario

Fans envision a dramatic return that could coincide with the holiday season, injecting a dose of high-stakes drama into Salem’s typically festive backdrop. Picture a stormy December night: snow blankets the town, Horton Christmas lights casting long, eerie shadows. Chad, still haunted by betrayal and loss, visits Abigail’s empty grave, whispering words of longing and regret. Out of the mist emerges a disheveled, wide-eyed figure—Blonde hair matted, clothes torn—whispering, “Chad…” The realization hits: Marcy Miller’s Abigail has returned, alive, changed, and bearing secrets from her ordeal.

The ensuing reunion promises to be electric, fraught with emotion, questions, and unresolved mysteries. Will Abigail remember her past fully? Has she been altered by her time away? Could she harbor a new persona beneath her familiar exterior? The possibilities are endless, and the impact on Chad, their children Thomas and Charlotte, and the broader Salem community cannot be overstated.

Fan Theories and Speculation

Social media is already ablaze with theories. Fans debate whether Abigail’s return will involve revenge, redemption, or reconciliation. Some speculate that her return will ignite new rivalries, reignite old romances, and perhaps even expose hidden truths within the Deveraux and Dera families. Soap forums teem with posts titled “Rumors & Wishes: Abigail’s Return,” where discussions range from recast speculation to predictions about how Miller’s dynamic energy will affect existing storylines.

One theory suggests Abigail has been held captive and brainwashed, her memory erased, only to rediscover her past through a chance encounter. Another imagines her return coinciding with a holiday disaster that forces the town to confront its darkest secrets. Across all theories, one consensus remains clear: Marcy Miller’s portrayal brings an irreplaceable combination of vulnerability and fire, unmatched by any previous portrayal. Fans are practically unanimous that any resurrection without Miller would feel hollow.

Challenges and Production Realities

While anticipation runs high, practical questions remain. Miller’s busy schedule, including film and theater commitments, could influence the timing and nature of her return. Production schedules for Days of Our Lives often require scenes to be filmed months in advance, meaning any December appearance could already be wrapped in secrecy. Additionally, storylines must seamlessly integrate Abigail’s return with ongoing arcs, ensuring that her re-entry enhances, rather than disrupts, the intricate web of Salem drama.

Despite these considerations, the precedent set by Days of Our Lives—resurrections, impostors, and miraculous recoveries—suggests that Abigail’s return is entirely plausible. From Bo Brady to Jason Morgan in other soaps, the genre has long embraced the impossible, delighting fans with unexpected reversals that redefine the stakes of daytime drama.

The Impact on Salem

Should Miller return as Abigail, the ramifications are enormous. Chad’s emotional journey, already strained by loss and betrayal, will be reignited. Family dynamics will be reshaped, with Jack and Jennifer navigating the complex reunion with their daughter. Long-buried secrets, past betrayals, and unresolved rivalries could all resurface, creating a cascade of conflict and tension that will ripple throughout Salem.

Moreover, Abigail’s return could redefine her legacy, allowing the character to reclaim her agency, confront adversaries, and assert her place as one of Salem’s most enduring figures. The drama, emotion, and suspense generated by Miller’s reappearance promise to captivate audiences, reigniting passion for a show that has consistently pushed the boundaries of daytime storytelling.

Waiting for the Miracle

As speculation swirls, fans wait with bated breath. Will December 2025 finally see the authentic Abigail Deveraux rise from the shadows, portrayed once again by Marcy Miller? Will she reunite with Chad, confront her past enemies, or reveal shocking truths about her time away? One thing is certain: in Salem, miracles are never impossible, and secrets rarely stay buried for long.