BREAKING NEWS : Soap Opera Critics Review Hits and Misses: Top 10 Moments of the Week January 19-23
The past week in daytime television proved once again why soap operas remain unmatched when it comes to emotional intensity, shocking twists, and bold creative risks.
From ruthless betrayals and power plays to controversial creative choices that left fans divided, the major soaps delivered a week packed with conversation-starting moments.
General Hospital and The Young and the Restless dominated the shock factor, while The Bold and the Beautiful, Days of Our Lives, and Beyond the Gates offered
a mix of inspired storytelling and frustrating missteps. Here’s a closer look at the biggest hits and misses that defined the week—and why viewers are still talking about them.
Top 5 Hits
5. Dr. Gregory Delivers Hard Truths to Brady (Days of Our Lives)
One of the most grounded and impactful scenes of the week came courtesy of Bayview psychiatrist Dr. Gregory. Following the unsettling discovery of young Rachel sneaking out and hiding in Sophia’s bed, Dr. Gregory sat Brady down for a frank, necessary conversation about boundaries, discipline, and parental responsibility. Rather than sugarcoating the situation, he reminded Brady that children absorb emotional chaos—and that Rachel’s troubling behavior is a reflection of the instability surrounding her parents’ love lives.
The scene worked because it didn’t rely on melodrama but on emotional realism. Dr. Gregory’s calm authority stood in stark contrast to the chaos around Brady and Kristen, reinforcing the idea that accountability—not excuses—is what Rachel needs most. The appearance of Kim Hawthorne in the role added gravitas and credibility, making this a standout moment that resonated far beyond the episode itself.
4. Steffy and Hope Clash Over Family—Not a Man (The Bold and the Beautiful)
In a refreshing change of pace, The Bold and the Beautiful allowed Steffy and Hope to clash over something other than Liam. Their argument centered on the potential romantic entanglement between their parents, raising legitimate concerns on both sides. Steffy, ever pragmatic, fears the fallout once Sheila inevitably learns about Deacon and Taylor’s connection—fully aware of Sheila’s dangerous history and capacity for destruction.
Hope, meanwhile, speaks from emotional exhaustion, desperate to protect her father from being hurt again. The debate felt earned, layered, and emotionally honest. By shifting the conflict away from romantic rivalry and toward family loyalty and fear, the show reminded viewers why these characters remain compelling when given material worthy of their complexity.
3. Shanice Stands Her Ground Against Leslie (Beyond the Gates)
Few characters this week showed as much backbone as Shanice. When Leslie stormed into the hospital to confront her over Ted, the showdown crackled with tension. Leslie’s possessive, territorial behavior has become increasingly volatile, but Shanice refused to be intimidated. Instead, she matched Leslie’s aggression beat for beat, asserting her dignity and refusing to back down.
The confrontation highlighted Shanice’s strength while also underlining Leslie’s escalating instability. With Leslie still circling and clearly unwilling to let go—despite her involvement with Marcel—the stakes are only rising. This was a textbook example of how soap confrontations should be written: personal, intense, and loaded with future consequences.
2. Victoria Newman Reclaims Her Power (The Young and the Restless)
Victoria Newman reminded everyone exactly why she is one of Genoa City’s most formidable forces. As Newman Enterprises faced devastation from a rogue AI threat, Victoria moved swiftly and decisively, teaming up with Adam and shutting down distractions—especially Billy’s emotional pleas.
Her most memorable moment, however, came when she confronted Cane and Phyllis. Without hesitation, she exposed Cane’s actions to Lily and Charlie, a ruthless but calculated move that sent shockwaves through multiple families. It was classic Victoria: strategic, unapologetic, and devastatingly effective. This was Newman power at its sharpest—and most satisfying.
1. Willow’s Ruthless Stroke of Revenge (General Hospital)
The week’s most jaw-dropping moment belonged to Willow. Fresh off her not-guilty verdict, she appeared calm, grateful, and relieved—until she was alone with Drew. In a chilling twist, Willow revealed just how far she was willing to go. With cold precision, she injected Drew with a substance that caused a massive stroke, eliminating him almost immediately.
The brutality of the move stunned viewers. There was no hesitation, no drawn-out planning arc—just swift, merciless action. Willow didn’t merely reclaim control of her life; she obliterated the man who threatened it. The moment redefined her character and cemented her place as one of the most dangerous players on the canvas.
Top 5 Misses
5. Peter August’s “Return” (General Hospital)
While Anna hallucinating Peter was undeniably surprising, the moment felt premature. The show earned points for shock value, but resurrecting Peter’s presence—however briefly—risked undermining the emotional weight of his previous exit. For many viewers, it was a twist that raised eyebrows rather than stakes.
4. Dani Kisses Bill (Beyond the Gates)
Dani leaning in to kiss Bill left fans stunned—and not necessarily in a good way. Given Dani’s current stable marriage and her complicated history with Bill, the move felt abrupt and out of character. The moment raised serious questions about whether Dani will come clean with Andre, or if this impulsive decision will spiral into something far messier.
3. Electra’s Overreaction at Dinner (The Bold and the Beautiful)
Electra’s explosive response to Dylan sharing a dinner with Will crossed the line from jealousy into unsettling territory. While her trauma is undeniable, the intensity of her reaction felt disproportionate and raised concerns about where the character is headed. Instead of sympathy, the scene left viewers uneasy.
2. The Custody Mediation Fallout (Days of Our Lives)
The custody mediation storyline frustrated many fans. Chad’s parenting was scrutinized without sufficient justification, and the judge’s response felt exaggerated. The fallout—particularly Thomas dictating boundaries—undermined Chad’s role as a parent and left the storyline feeling heavy-handed and emotionally manipulative.
1. Victor Controls Matt Clark’s Fate (The Young and the Restless)
Allowing Victor to determine Matt Clark’s fate felt like a misstep. Matt isn’t Victor’s primary adversary, and the decision diluted the personal stakes for Nick and Sharon. Victor’s involvement shifted focus away from the emotional core of the conflict, weakening what could have been a more character-driven resolution.
Final Thoughts
This week in daytime drama showcased the genre at both its boldest and most frustrating. When soaps lean into character-driven conflict and emotional truth, the results are unforgettable. When shortcuts replace nuance, viewers notice just as quickly. With fallout from these moments already unfolding, the coming weeks promise even more reckoning, reversals, and revelations—proving once again that in the world of soap operas, nothing stays quiet for long.

